It seems that almost everyone who is a sports fan – even a casual one, is happy if not excited that the Detroit Lions are 5-0 for the first time since Lincoln was President. I for one am with them, although I can’t really figure out why. I have no ties to Detroit. No family in Michigan. In fact, I have been a life-long Ohio State fan, which means I hate Michigan. But for some reason I love the fact that this franchise is back on track and sticking it to their rivals. I feel the same way about the Buffalo Bills and even the 49er’s (Who I have a valid case to despise since they handed the Chargers one of the worst losses in Super Bowl history.).
But it occurred to me that perhaps the reason I feel good about these particular franchises being successful is because it’s better for the sport when they are. No one wants the Yankees to win, but it’s better for baseball when they’re involved because of the hatred/adoration/casual interest they provoke. There are just some teams this rule inexplicabably applies to and here for the first time I’m going to try and explic it. I now introduce the first ever NFL Impact Rankings.
Now this list will be based on a few components:
1) History in the NFL.
2) Fan base.
3) Ratings when given the opportunity.
4) Casual recognition.
5) Experience with the Super Bowl (good or bad).
The Robert De Niro Tier or The Top-Of-The-Line Tier:
Green Bay Packers – Current champs. Most storied franchise in the league. Great uniforms and when they win your father and grandfather are happy, which means it’s important. Even if they’ve just won a Super Bowl, it feels like it’s been forever since the last time and that means they’ve been with you for a long time.
Chicago Bears – Take away the current champs comment and you get the same description as the Packers. Also both teams have bitter rivalries, which always keeps fans and the media involved. Both fans sit in the worst weather possible to watch their boys play and that happens only a few other places in all of sport.
Pittsburgh Steelers – Storied franchise. Multiple Super Bowls and always evoke emotion in superfans and casual fans whether it’s good or bad.
Detroit Lions – Again, long history in the NFL. Haven’t won anything since the 50’s which gives them the added, “I never thought in my lifetime” scenario that makes your grandpa cry and you smile. Lovable losers, who give everyone hope. Heated rivalries and great fans.
New England Patriots – Now this team would have not been a part of this tier in the 1990’s, but they have become so ingrained in the collective pop-culture of causal fans and superfans that you can’t leave them off the top tier. They aren’t near like the Yankees of the NFL, but most people consider them the evil empire. Evoke emotion + success + superstars = better for the sport when you win.
The Liam Neeson Tier or The Almost Top-Tier-But-Are-Missing-A-Few-Components Tier:
Dallas Cowboys – If this was the late 80’s or early 90’s they would have been in the Patriots spot but its not and they aren’t. Even when Tony Romo was dating Jessica Simpson it seemed like most people were bummed it wasn’t Britney. They have a crazy owner and a ridiculous stadium, which both hurt them more than help them. Even superfans hate a crazy owner and a brand new stadium lives little nostalgia for a casual fan. Also, for reasons that escape me they’re probably one of the most universally hated teams in the league (Maybe all the cocaine?)
Buffalo Bills – They have the great distinction of being the only team to play in four consecutive Super Bowls and the only team to lose four consecutive Super Bowls. They dominated most of the 80’s and 90’s but fell off the grid in ’99 and haven’t sniffed the playoffs since. However, they have insanely devoted fans. A movie made about them, an indie one at that (Buffalo ’66) and play in cold weather. Constant threats of moving is the only thing that shifts them down to this tier.
Cleveland Browns – They haven’t won a championship since 1964, which gives them the tortured franchise “almost made it” tag that people love. But, they’ve moved and then moved back. This drops them down. Their two biggest assets are that the media loves them when they’re good and they have great fans. Also, great uniforms. Also, have no foreseeable way to right their ship.
San Francisco 49ers – This is a touchy one, but their association with two of the greatest quarterbacks of all time, their domination in the late 80’s and early 90’s and their sweet uniforms make them a shoe in for second tier impact. When they’re good the media hops all over them. They’re the only team in California that gets respect from superfans and as of the last decade have accumulated tons of underdog status. They have a great fan base and are very recognizable even to the casual fan. They’re not in the top tier mainly because they’re a west coast team and west coast sports are always considered ‘less-than’ by purists (read: old people).
Oakland Raiders – People hate them, but they’ve played NFL villains to a tee. When they’re good they’re mean, tough and fast. When they’re bad they’re soft, confused and boring. Their fan base will kill you and their pirate logo is a staple of sports for casual and superfans alike.
Philadelphia Eagles – If it weren’t for their great, sometimes horrifically violent fans they would’ve dropped a tier. The Eagles are almost never fun to watch, they even made McNabb boring. But, they’ve been around since the 30’s so they have history and they haven’t won a Super Bowl since 1960 so they have hope. But, they have little appeal to the casual fan and don’t travel well. On the upside Invincible was actually a pretty good flick.
The Gary Oldman Tier or The How-Could-You-Not-Put-This-Team-In-The-Top-Two-Tiers Tier:
New York Jets – They have a long rag-tag history playing professional football. They won it all in 1968 and tend to grace the playoffs about twice a decade. They have superfans, but are almost never important to causal fans. Although Broadway Joe skyrocketed them to the forefront, no one has cared since.
New York Giants – They have seven titles, they’re one of the original five NFL teams from 1925 and they’ve been successful for a good portion of that time. The problem is no one seems to care. They have a crazy fan base, but outside of New York they might as well be the Jets. They’re mostly boring and no one seems to like they’re current roster or coaching staff, which has taken them out of the media spotlight over the past decade. Even when they won the Super Bowl, the only things people talked about were “the catch” and the Patriots losing it. And Little Giants sucked.
Minnesota Vikings – Least cared about team in their division and the rest of their division are all in the Top Tier. They have been “possibly moving” since 1999 and play in the worst looking dome on TV, which kills their media appeal. When a 60-year sexting QB is you’re biggest draw since 1998 it’s not a good sign. Plus, terrible uniforms.
Washington Redskins – It’s amazing how one owner can destroy a franchise and anyone’s interest in them, but Snyder has done it.
Indianapolis Colts – They’re a transplant team. Little casual fan appeal and we’ve found out that without Peyton this team not only sucks but they’re irrelevant. Art Donovan is pretty awesome though.
The Sam Rockwell Tier or The-I-Like-Them-But-Don’t-Know-If-They’re-Great-Or-Just-OK Tier:
Cincinnati Bengals – They seem like they should be higher on this list, but they aren’t. It’s nice when the Bengals do well, because they almost never do. But casual fans certainly don’t care and superfans almost care. They have little fan sympathy and don’t do well with the media. Booomer!
Denver Broncos – Great rabid fans and a franchise no one has cared about since Elway. We’re getting a brief resurgence with Tebow, but that doesn’t work for this list. Sorry.
New Orleans Saints – When they’re good people love them and I mean all people, but when they’re bad no one cares about them at and I mean no one. And the problem with that last sentence is that they’ve been bad 80% of the time since 1967.
The James McAvoy Tier or The-I-Know-I’ve-Seen-Them-Play-And-I-Don’t-Ever-Mind-It-When-I-Do Tier:
San Diego Chargers – People love the Chargers and their throwback jerseys are the best uniforms in professional sports, but they can barely sell out home games and the media all but ignores them.
Miami Dolphins – A team that will always have clout because of Dan Marino and 1972. That’s it.
Atlanta Falcons – Remember when Michael Vick played there? Cool uniforms and people do tend to enjoy the team if they’re playing well.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers – Their throwback uniforms are fantastic.
St. Louis Rams – Oh how far they have fallen. They only appear in such a high tier because of 1997-1999.
Arizona Cardinals – Another surprise on this tier and another team that can thank Kurt Warner for being here. I was shocked how much people wanted them to win that Super Bowl. Go Cards!
And lastly the Jason Schwartzman Tier or The-Outside-Of-A-Certain-Zip-Code-No-One-Cares-A-Lick-About-Them Tier:
Seattle Seahawks – Even hiring Pete Carroll couldn’t drum up long-lasting interest in this team.
Kansas City Chiefs – Rabid superfans but they’re all alone.
Baltimore Ravens – Ray Lewis.
Carolina Panthers – Yes, they played in a Super Bowl.
Houston Texans – I guarantee 50% of the casual fan and 25% of NFL fans are convinced they’re still called the Oilers.
Tennessee Titans – A transplant team that became well known for being talked about in Cast Away.
P.S. Tier:
Jacksonville Jaguars
There it is: The first ever Impact Ranking. Am I wrong? Tell me why…